My first Japanese-style RPG was Dragon Warrior 1 or Final Fantasy 1--can't remember which came first, probably DW. Played just about all the SNES RPGs before I ever touched a Playstation. I still like FFVII the best of all. It had the task of toppling FF3/6 in my book, and that it did.
People I know around my age (20-21-22-23) grew up mainly on the NES and SNES/Genesis. I started with the Atari 2600. There is high respect for FFVII still. Coming from the GameFAQs system, I know everyone there was basically obsessed with it. It remained the number 1 FAQ page for years, and these guys I knew were a special breed of hardcore gamer. Yes, it was popular. Does it make it good? Not popularity, but what defines good?